考研英语一2017年大作文实例分析与批改

2017年考研英语一大作文围绕哪一类话题命题？本文精选的范文聚焦考研英语一作文真题话题方向，结合启航教育多年考研英语一教学沉淀，从描述图表、解读寓意到发表评论三大角度，完整呈现高分作文的内在结构。

一、考研英语一2017年大作文题目

考研英语一2017年大作文52. Directions: Write an essay of 160-200 words based on the following pictures. In your essay, you should1) describe the pictures briefly, 2) interpret the meaning, and 3) give your comments. You should write neatly on the ANSWER SHEET. (20 points)

二、考研英语一2017年大作文批改例文

This theme of the drawing is about "having books" and "reading books". In the left picture, there is a people, sitting a stool, whose opposite is a bookshelf, filled with books. The people says that "I have so many books". In the right picture, there is a people, who sits in front of the table where there are many books, which are read seemingly. In this drawing, he says that "I struggle to read 20 books this year"

From the comparison between these two pictures, we can know both two situations are "having books", but the left is "having books" just the physical level. The right is "having books" in his heart. It tells us whether we have books not depends up physical level but if we genuinely read them to let us understand them.

What I want to say is that maybe there are many things, which as long as we possess them, we can say we have it, but there also are many things, which only by personal experience, we can say we have it. The books are one of them.

三、考研英语作文批改

原文：s theme of the drawing is about "having books" and "reading books". In the left picture, there is a people, sitting a stool, whose opposite is a bookshelf, filled with books. The people says that "I have so many books". In the right picture, there is a people, who sits in front of the table where there are many books, which are read seemingly. In this drawing, he says that "I struggle to read 20 books this year"

批改：你清楚地描述了两幅图的场景和对话，核心信息都捕捉到了

原文： the comparison between these two pictures, we can know both two situations are "having books", but the left is "having books" just the physical level. The right is "having books" in his heart. It tells us whether we have books not depends up physical level but if we genuinely read them to let us understand them.

批改：这一段准确地指出了漫画的核心寓意，即物理拥有和内心拥有的区别，观点非常棒！我们可以把句子组织得更流畅、更严谨。

原文：can say we have it, but there also are many things, which only by personal experience, we can say we have it. The books are one of them.

批改：这是全文的亮点！你将主题从“书籍”升华到更广阔的人生领域，指出有些东西需要亲身经历才能真正“拥有”，这个思考非常深刻，极大地提升了文章的立意。

原文：e can know both two situ

批改：“we can know both two situations”： both 和 two 意思重复，保留一个即可，both situations 或 the two situations。

原文： depends up

批改：“depends up”： 正确的短语是 depend on。

原文：e is a people, who sits

批改：“a people”： 这是一个非常重要的语法点。people 是集体名词，表示“人们”，本身就是复数。指代单个人时，要用 a person。所以全文中的 a people 都需要改为 a person。 “sitting a stool”： “坐在凳子上”的正确表达是 sitting on a stool，介词 on 不能省略。

四、考研英语作文评分

得分：15

你这篇作文最大的亮点在于思想的深度。你没有被漫画的表面意思局限，而是能够提炼出“真正的拥有在于内在消化而非物理占有”这一普适哲理，这是非常可贵的思维能力，也是高分作文的核心要素。

在语言表达上，你已经能够清晰地传递思想。下一步要追求的，是让形式更好地服务于内容。我给你的核心建议是：

攻克“经典小错误”：请务必掌握 a person (非a people) 和 depend on (非depend up) 这类基础但至关重要的语法点和固定搭配。避免这些错误能给你的作文打下坚实的印象分基础。

优化句子结构：当你想表达复杂逻辑时，可以尝试先写出句子的主干（谁做了什么），再添加修饰成分。对于你原文中那些由 which 引导的、结构稍显复杂的句子，可以思考是否能拆分成两个短句，或者用更简洁的方式（如介词短语 for many things）来重组，这样会使行文更流畅、有力。

启航教育2027考研英语斌哥写作锦囊冲刺抢分班，精选36句锦囊妙句，搭建考研英语写作素材库；6个高分写作模板，搞定不同文体考研英语一作文。无论你是考研英语一一还是考研英语一二考生，都能从中获益。欢迎在线咨询了解更多。